The mental court: Ego and confidence
Brook Van Ham, Staff Writer
The 2024 Super Bowl showcased Travis Kelce as having a big ego when he was left out of a play, running over to coach Andy Reid, physically and verbally attacking him. Unfortunately for Kelce, the incident was on a worldwide broadcast, but he did not seem to face any repercussions.
Competitive play challenges athletes to constantly perform their best. To what extent do these pressures account for the mindsets and mental responses athletes have on and off the field?
Ego entitlement
Every individual athlete is different, but fans often see common themes, especially around athlete egos.
Whether it is valid or unprecedented scrutiny, only an athlete understands the amount they put in for the outcome seen in a game. Viewers truly only get a snippet of the commitment, hours and mental battles athletes put in each day.
Therefore, when an athlete is confident in themselves and their sport, it could at times be easily misinterpreted. The line between ego and confidence can be blurred, and differs by perception.
“Confidence is thinking ‘I believe I can do this’ whereas ego might be more ‘if I do this I prove something to others,’” says sports psychologist Lesley Tims.
Ego typically carries a negative connotation around it, suggesting focus on individual status, arrogance and a need for external validation. Motivation can be found through striving to always be the best and desiring to hold oneself in a certain esteem.
“It can also be used as a positive tool as well,” says Tims, challenging the typical assumptions that high-egos are purely damaging.
After the buzzer
The determination of benefit or harm from an ego seems to fall more on the athlete’s ability to separate themselves from the actual outcome or actions during the game.
The ability to rally is essential in a good athlete, and this is where ego can at times get in the way, as it is less grounded in reality than confidence.
“Ego is your perception of yourself having a detrimental effect on your goals,” says Mount Royal Cougars men’s basketball head coach Josh Mullen.
Mullen looks at confidence as grounded in reality, rooted in belief in oneself based on work ethic or experience. Confidence, in other terms, is a growth mindset, or a key part of it.
When talking about extremely successful teams and athletes—some who went on to play professionally—tremendous confidence is evident.
“The best teams, the players, are incredibly comfortable in their own skin,” Mullen says.
Mullen emphasises how the mindset needed to play well and to believe that “no moment is ever too big” expands on the necessary conviction in oneself.
In the society we know, it is rare to hear and see an individual refusing limitations. Ego can also be a tool, something to use as a shield.
“It could be hiding a fear of failure, especially when winning becomes tied to your identity,” says Tims.
Humanising very successful athletes can be a reminder that the media is often one-sided in comparison to the actual story.
The division
This is where the distinction can be made: ego will not be going to know personal limitations and boundaries, while confidence will. Confident players may be comfortable in one position, but understanding another teammate’s approach is stronger in certain scenarios, stepping out to contribute to the overall goals.
Ego would more likely convince the athlete to step in at every moment, holding an unrealistic perception or desire that they must always be the champion.
There is a broad range of characteristics that can come with both ego and confidence, and raises the consideration of the balance between arrogance and humility.
To perceive all athletes as egotistical would be rooted in complete misunderstanding and unfair generalisation. However, that is certainly not to say there are some who have been inflated by the attention and triumphs, perhaps negatively representing the sport and competitive culture.
As in any field, there are differing individuals within. Although there may be real patterns that lead to painting the entire group in one way, it is not plausible to do so.
In the future, can these embedded assumptions about egocentrism be reconsidered, with public scrutiny in mind? Or can they be viewed with the reassurance that the reasoning is justified?

Zlatan Ibrahimovic is commonly referred to as one of the most egotistical pro athletes, commonly comparing himself to a god. Photo courtesy of GOAL / Facebook


